Microsoft raised the bar for Windows PCs with its Surface computers, despite low share after a decade

Panos Panay, chief product officer of Microsoft Corp., shows the new Surface Laptop 3 laptop throughout a Microsoft product occasion in New York on Oct. 2, 2019. Microsoft unveiled a dual-screen, foldable cellphone that can run on Google’s Android working system, leaping again into a promote it exited years in the past.

Mark Kauzlarich | Bloomberg | Getty Images

Microsoft made a splash in 2012 when it launched the Surface, the first laptop it had inbuilt its 37 years of existence. The computer systems are nonetheless kicking 10 years later, with Microsoft issuing annual updates, however Surface’s mega-growth is lengthy in the previous.

Microsoft tried to reimagine tablets, that are made common by the iPad, when it launched into the PC market. In 2012, the Surface with Windows RT, later named Surface RT, was extra than simply a touchscreen slab like Apple’s iPad. The Surface may act as a full PC with an non-compulsory cowl that includes a keyboard and trackpad.

Apple in the ensuing years would make the iPad extra like the Surface, including comparable equipment, whereas Microsoft would do what it often does: Roll out a collection of small updates. It later added new Surface computer systems to the household, together with an all-in-one PC, a commonplace laptop computer and miniature variations of the Surface.

Those steps have caused development. In Microsoft’s most up-to-date fiscal yr, Surface kicked in $6.7 billion of the firm’s $198 billion in whole income. That’s greater than the whole income of over 100 firms in the S&P 500 index.

But the hyper-growth vanished after the first three years. In the 2022 fiscal yr, Surface income elevated by 3%, despite being smaller than PC initiatives at a number of different firms. Apple’s Mac enterprise, at virtually $38 billion, grew about 8% over the similar interval.

Surfaces simply aren’t as common as different computer systems. They have by no means managed to take greater than 2.1% market share of PC shipments, in line with an estimate from expertise trade researcher Gartner. Lenovo has a 25% share of the market, whereas HP has 19% and Dell has 18%, respectively.

Microsoft declined to touch upon whether or not it considers Surface profitable.

“We design Surface to be the one place where the best of Microsoft comes together, delighting customers and inspiring the Windows ecosystem,” a spokesperson instructed CNBC in an e-mail. “Surface began as a tablet to replace your laptop, showcasing Windows capabilities like touch, ink, Windows Hello, and more. Since then, the 2-in-1 category has taken off and Surface has grown into an innovative portfolio of products offering premium designs and capabilities that consistently earn high customer satisfaction.” 

That Surface has not surpassed extra skilled PC makers won’t be such a unhealthy factor anyway. PC builders are amongst Microsoft’s most outstanding purchasers as a result of they pay Microsoft a price for the copy of Windows that goes on every laptop. Upstaging them won’t be sensible.

Surface has held on to an essential position — bringing to market Windows PCs with contemporary designs, Gartner analyst Mikako Kitagawa instructed CNBC in an interview.

“I think those are the things they should really focus on, instead of looking for share gain and revenue growth,” she mentioned.

If Microsoft have been to cost ahead in pursuit of dominant share, they may kill their prospects, she mentioned. Kitagawa recalled that Windows PC makers have been not very happy with Microsoft when the first Surfaces arrived. “Taking 3% share was taking from somebody, right? That’s not incremental share,” she mentioned.

Premium really feel

Microsoft Corp.’s Surface pill computer systems, aiming to compete with Apple’s iPad, are displayed at Hollywood’s Milk Studios in Los Angeles Monday, June 18, 2012. The 9.3-millimeter thick pill comes with a kickstand to carry it upright and keyboard that’s a part of the system’s cowl. (AP Photo/Damian Dovarganes)

Damian Dovarganes

The first line of the news release about the 2012 Surface confirmed Microsoft’s intent. These computer systems have been meant to be “the ultimate stage for Windows.” A piece close to the backside acknowledged the purchasers that have been instantly turning into the competitors. “Microsoft is delivering a unique contribution to an already strong and growing ecosystem of functional and stylish devices delivered by original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) to bring the experience of Windows to consumers and businesses around the globe,” the firm mentioned.

The inaugural Surface, the Surface RT operating Windows RT, boasted intelligent bodily attributes. A skinny however sturdy kickstand may sweep out and prop up the show on a desk or a desk. The case was made out of magnesium in a course of known as VaporMg, which lends it a premium really feel akin to the aluminum wrapping up Apple’s MacBooks. An non-compulsory magnetic Touch Cover contained a slender keyboard and a trackpad that doubled as a cowl for the show. An influence-sipping Arm chip gave it respectable battery life.

But the Surface RT blocked individuals from opening applications that weren’t listed in Microsoft’s app retailer, stopping them from utilizing most present Windows software program. Basically, there wasn’t a lot you might do with it, and lots of third-party builders hadn’t executed the work to adapt their software program to it. The system garnered lower than glowing critiques, with The Verge calling it “honestly perplexing.” “Little inconsistencies and bafflements are everywhere,” The New York Times’ David Pogue wrote.

Microsoft Surface with Windows 8 Pro


In 2013 Microsoft introduced out the Surface RT’s dearer and extra highly effective sibling, the Surface Pro. It contained a stylus, alongside with an Intel chip that would run actual Windows applications, with stronger efficiency than the Surface RT.

For Microsoft to place forth a extra conventional Intel-based Windows PC can be daring. It would instantly problem a few of the firm’s high purchasers. “It did not seem prudent,” Steven Sinofsky, president of Microsoft’s Windows division who left the firm in 2012, wrote in “Hardcore Software,” a detailed recollection of his expertise that he is been publishing in elements on Substack. Windows was Microsoft’s essential supply of revenue. If even one in every of the main Windows system makers have been to cease constructing Windows PCs, that will be, in Sinofsky’s phrases, “a massive problem.”

Microsoft pressed on anyway.

Like the Arm-based Surface RT, the Intel-powered Surface Pro wasn’t excellent. It may solely run for a few hours on a single cost, and it was heavy and impractical to use as a pill. And common laptops provided better keyboards than those who Microsoft offered individually for the Surface Pro.

Cutting into revenue

Microsoft’s Surface Laptop Go 2 begins at $599.


A number of months later Microsoft revealed a black eye. It trimmed the value of the Surface RT by $150 to $349 and instituted stock changes for associated elements and equipment, which resulted in a $596 million discount in its quarterly web earnings.

But Microsoft did what it often does. It caught with the Surface line as an alternative of ditching a challenged model. It rolled out refinements, corresponding to making the hinge on the again of the pill adjustable and altering the side ratio in such a means that work grew to become extra comfy in panorama orientation.

  1. By 2015, Microsoft had walked away from Windows RT and was centered on constructing gadgets with Intel chips that would run commonplace Windows purposes.

Meanwhile, copycats were coming out from high PC makers corresponding to Dell, HP and Lenovo. And Apple was additionally responding, rolling out the laptop-like 12.9-inch iPad Pro and appropriate Apple Pencil stylus and Smart Keyboard cowl in 2015.

It was a sturdy dose of validation for Microsoft. In 2012, earlier than the Surface got here out, and there have been solely rumors of Microsoft’s plans for Windows, Apple CEO Tim Cook instructed analysts that “you can converge a toaster and a refrigerator, but those things are probably not going to be pleasing to the user.”

Yet in 2017, Apple, maybe Microsoft’s hardest company critic, capitulated. It got here out with a toaster-refrigerator combo of its personal, mentioned Michael Gartenberg, a expertise trade strategist and former Gartner analyst. “It’s clearly become a mainstream design,” Gartenberg mentioned.

Also that yr Microsoft launched the Surface Laptop. While it was as boring as some other laptop computer, it disregarded the software program that generally may burden Windows PCs from different producers, the kinds of issues finish customers may wish to spend time deleting, Gartenberg mentioned.

Microsoft Corp. floor 5 laptop computer computer systems on show at the firm’s Ignite Spotlight occasion in Seoul, South Korea, on Nov. 15, 2022. CEO Satya Nadella gave a keynote speech at an occasion hosted by the firm’s Korean unit.

SeongJoon Cho | Bloomberg | Getty Images

In 2019, Microsoft took one other shot at an Arm-based Surface, with the Surface Pro X. Reviewers gave it credit score for long battery life however dinged it for efficiency and compatibility causes, not in contrast to the authentic Surface RT.

This yr, Microsoft made issues extra advanced by introducing an Intel-based Surface Pro 9 alongside with an Arm-based model, which put an finish to the distinct model for Arm-flavored Surface. People have fretted that the Arm mannequin of the Pro 9 continues to be unable to run some applications. The Intel model has obtained extra reward. “The removal of the headphone jack is the only new thing that’s wrong with it,” Ars Technica mentioned in its assessment.

Those who decide for the Surface Pro 9 with an Arm chip can a minimum of entry a broad swath of apps. The 2022 replace to Windows 11 consists of a technique to run over 50,000 Android apps by means of the Amazon Appstore.

If you have a look at it for simply a second, the Surface Pro 9 with Intel inside appears a bit like the 10-year-old Surface RT. Changes in and out have made it harder to dismiss as a novelty. There’s a button to allow the Function row on the keyboard, which boasts a extra responsive trackpad. Enhancements to Windows make it simpler to faucet buttons on the display screen when utilizing the Surface as a pill. You can open the applications you want.

Surface Pro 9, Surface Laptop 5 and Surface Studio 2+.


Gartenberg, who lives in New Jersey, would not see many individuals utilizing Surfaces in the actual world, though he did not too long ago witness a man engaged on a Surface whereas strolling round outdoors. The man was carrying a harness that held the Surface simply off his chest, so he may faucet on the display screen when crucial, Gartenberg mentioned.

There’s one place you may definitely see them, although. During televised video games, you may spot gamers, coaches and referees utilizing branded Surface machines at National Football League video games as a results of a partnership Microsoft struck with the NFL in 2013.

Buffalo Bills line of defense coach Eric Washington critiques performs on a Microsoft Surface pill

Robin Alam | Icon Sportswire | Getty Images

In the course of a decade, Microsoft has managed to lift the bar for Windows PC makers, demonstrating that a high tier of Windows can exist, Gartenberg mentioned.

“If someone said to me, ‘I need a Windows PC,’ what would I recommend? I would say, ‘Go see what Microsoft is offering. Go see if that meets your needs,’” he mentioned. “‘It’s not going to come with any junk you’re going to call me about, and it will just work.’”

‘No compromise by any means’

Still, it isn’t very straightforward to find Surface diehards. A number of might be discovered by browsing Craigslist.

There is, for instance, Stephane Prunet, an funding advisor in Berkeley, California. For years the system’s unconventional design has appealed to him. He purchased a Surface Pro 3 after which a Surface Pro 7. The latter, which got here out in 2019, is his essential laptop, and he runs Microsoft Excel and different work-related applications on it.

“I almost never use it as a tablet. Maybe I should, but I don’t,” he mentioned. Earlier this month he listed each on Craigslist. If somebody buys the Surface Pro 7 for a good value, he’ll improve to the Surface Pro 9, which has a bigger show.

If not, he mentioned, he’ll grasp on to the 3-year-old Surface. He will not be giving it away to one in every of his kids. His daughter makes use of a Mac, and his son is completely happy with his personal Windows laptop computer. “He’s never shown interest in the Surface,” Prunet mentioned.

Sure, some individuals may need a larger display screen, however past that, he would not perceive how individuals can be higher off with a common laptop computer than with a Surface.

“Except the fact that maybe some laptops are less expensive. That’s probably an explanation,” he mentioned. “Because otherwise, I find there is no compromise whatsoever. In fact, there are only benefits. The keyboard is very comfy. It’s not as rigid as a laptop, but who cares?”

WATCH: The Microsoft Surface Go is a good computer, but a very bad tablet

Leave a Comment